ICHRA or a group plan: how to tell which one your company is

An Individual Coverage HRA sounds like an obvious answer to an unpredictable renewal: set a monthly amount, let people buy their own plan, reimburse it tax-free, and stop negotiating with carriers. Sometimes it is exactly that. The decision turns on two things, and neither of them is the HRA design.

The first thing: what the individual market looks like where your people live

An ICHRA is only as good as the plans your employees can actually buy. A workforce spread across metropolitan areas with four or five carriers and broad networks has real choice. A workforce in a county with one carrier and a narrow network has been handed a budget and no options.

This is a per-employee question, not a company-level one, and it is the first thing to check rather than the last. Look at the actual plans available in each employee’s rating area before you look at anything else.

The second thing: how old your workforce is

Individual premiums rise steeply with age — the permitted ratio is roughly three to one between the oldest and youngest adults. Group premiums for a composite rate do not vary that way for the employee.

So a flat ICHRA contribution buys a twenty-eight-year-old a good plan and a fifty-eight-year-old a poor one. You can vary the contribution by age within permitted classes, which fixes the arithmetic. Whether it fixes the perception is a separate question, and one worth thinking about before the announcement rather than after.

Where ICHRA genuinely wins

  • Employees in many states. No network can serve them all; individual coverage serves each person locally.
  • Low participation on the group plan. If half your people waive because a spouse covers them, you are paying to maintain a plan for half a group and probably failing participation tests.
  • Budget certainty above all. Your cost is what you set it to. There is no renewal.
  • Groups that cannot pass participation requirements at all. ICHRA has none.

Where it does not

  • Thin individual markets. Already covered, and it is decisive.
  • An older workforce, unless you vary contributions by class and fund the older classes properly.
  • A workforce used to a rich group plan. Employees will read it as a cut, whatever the arithmetic says, unless the contribution is genuinely generous.
  • Employers who want one plan to talk about. With ICHRA, everybody has a different plan, and benefits questions become individual rather than collective.

The compliance part people underestimate

An ICHRA is a group health plan. It needs a written plan document and an SPD. It needs a notice to eligible employees at least ninety days before the plan year starts, explaining the amount, the classes, and the effect on any premium tax credit. It needs a substantiation process proving each employee actually holds individual coverage every month. ERISA applies. Depending on size, so does Form 5500.

And if you are an applicable large employer, §4980H still applies. Affordability is tested against the lowest-cost silver plan in each employee’s own rating area — so the answer differs employee by employee, and it has to be calculated rather than assumed.

QSEHRA, the smaller cousin

Fewer than fifty full-time equivalents, no group health plan at all, IRS-set annual maximums that are considerably lower than what an ICHRA permits, and the same amount for every eligible employee. Much less administration. Where it fits, it fits well.

How to actually decide

Price all three — your renewal, an ICHRA at a contribution that buys a comparable silver plan for your median employee, and a level-funded quote — against the same census. Then look at what the ICHRA contribution buys your oldest employee in their own zip code, because that is the case that determines whether this lands as a benefit or as a cut.

More on how ICHRA works, or send us your census and we will check the markets.

General information for employers, not legal or tax advice.

All insights Request a review
Request a review

Send the renewal, and we will tell you what we would change

No fee, and no obligation to move the business. Most employers who contact us are simply trying to work out whether the number in front of them is a fair one.

We reply to enquiries within one business day. We do not sell or share contact details.

Waugh Agency has advised employers on health and welfare benefits since 1985. Our full site — including Medicare, individual and travel coverage — is at waughagency.com.